"Two Stripes and You're Out!" Says Adidas

Two recent trademark infringement cases have attacked the legality of products sold at Payless ShoeSource ("Payless"), a shoe store known for selling name brand look-alikes at discount prices.

Adidas AG alleged in 2001 that Collective Brands, the owner of Payless, sold 272 different models of shoes that infringed Adidas's three-stripe logo. Adidas declared that the three-stripe logo was equivalent to the Adidas brand itself, and pointed out the popularity of the mark worldwide. While Payless never sold shoes bearing an exact replica of the three-stripe design, a jury found on May 5, 2008, that shoes with both two and four stripes infringed the Adidas mark, and that all but one of the 272 models to which Adidas objected infringed the company's trademark. The jury awarded Adidas $305 million in actual and punitive damages and ordered Payless to disgorge profits of $137 million. The jury awarded punitive damages upon finding that Collective Brands willfully infringed Adidas's trademark and recklessly disregarded its intellectual property rights. Collective Brands, claiming the award is excessive and unreasonable, has asked the judge to overrule or reduce the amount awarded.

K-Swiss, a California-based company that makes tennis shoes bearing a five-stripe design, announced on June 27, 2008, that it reached a $30 million settlement agreement with Collective Brands following claims that Collective Brands is also selling shoes that infringe the K-Swiss trademark. Collective Brands agreed not to sell or advertise confusingly-similar products, and it has until the end of the year to sell existing inventory.

Collective Brands is not the first company to mimic the three-stripe logo, although the sheer quantity of its similar models and its large profits from look-alike shoes make it an attractive target for Adidas.

In hopes that it will receive additional favorable rulings with respect to look-alike products, Adidas has recently sued Walmart. It claims that Walmart's tennis shoes bearing two- and four-stripe designs amount to infringement of Adidas's trademark. Walmart is one of three dozen retailers Adidas has sued in infringement claims in the United States and Europe since 1999.

As the world's second largest sporting-goods maker, second only to Nike, Adidas is trying to protect what has become one of the most valuable and well-known trademarks worldwide.